"COASTER BRAKE WARS" Patents - 1,069,603 (Copeland) & 850,077 (Townsend)
Below you will find the two primary patents that led to the "Coaster Brake Wars".
Patent #1,069,603, "Driving and Braking Mechanism for Vehicles", was filed on April 29, 1898 by J.S. Copeland, inventor, on behalf of the American Bicycle Company but eventually assigned to the New Departure Manufacturing Company when the patent was finally granted on August 15, 1913 fifteen years later. This fifteen year period is what I term the "Coaster Brake Wars".
Patent #850,077, "Driving and Braking Mechanism for Cycles", was filed on October 10, 1898 by H.P. Townsend, inventor, on behalf of the New Departure Bell Company but eventually assigned to the now named New Departure Manufacturing Company when the patent was finally granted on April 9, 1907 nine years later. During the coaster brake wars the major issue became which was designed first and in the end this was deemed to be the first coaster brake design having begun development in 1897. I noted in an earlier post that New Departure was rarely mentioned in "The Bicycling World and Motorcycle Review" from 1902 to late 1907 and I suspect the granting of their patent first of the two, forced many hands behind the scenes to bring New Departure back into view in this bicycle trade weekly.
There were arguments on both sides of their designs development in late 1897 during numerous lawsuits and patent infringement cases that kept both from being patented for years.
The "Coaster Brake Wars" began in 1899 and continued until 1913 from what I have found so far. It would take a lot more research to determine the details of all the various parties during this timeframe but the biggest standoff was probably Pope Manufacturing's Colonel Albert Pope against New Departure's Albert Rockwell from the little details I have read.
Copeland's Patent #1,069,603
Townsend's Patent #850,077