Are those the pointy front ones? I will be in Vegas in 12 days.
I think the fenders would be the same as on my '65 Varsity.
Here's a pic to show what they look like.
View attachment 1678430
I think you're right about the fenders on your 65 except, humm,, did Schwinn use that fancy or regular reflector? I also think there's another option; for a few bucks less, you would be riding on painted fenders.
Regardless, since 'pointy fenders ended in 63, the fenders 64 and up, I think, fenders aren't date stamped and so, the only difference for another 10 years or more, on all the Chicago made 'lightweights' is painted or chrome and which reflector ya got on it.
My 68 Super Sport Tourist has same fenders as your 65, with that rear reflector, but reflector base is white vs chrome.