I've been looking at the New Departure "NOS" parts I've been buying on ebay. Wondered what you thought of this?
The "NOS" bearings I've received, for the most part, do not have the "New Departure" name stamps on the cages and the cages themselves are not formed as nicely as the original ND hubs on Gramp's bike. Maybe the tooling was worn, or different when these cages where fabricated. Here's a bearing I got with the "NOS New Departure WL Front Axle Assembly" I ordered next to the original from Gramp's bike with New Departure stamp in the cage.
The holes that the balls sit in are not formed (stamped) as cleanly and there is a ridge all the way around most of them, formed by the worn or different tooling. What happened to the "NEW DEPARTURE" name stamp on top???
Closer look at the clean vs ridges holes.
Maybe it's not a big deal since it's just the cages but why so different? Did they start skipping the deburring step after they got stamped?? The people at New Departure were proud enough of their work/design to stamp their name on top of the cage for a reason. I know first hand about tooling redesign and yearly cost downs, so I'm not claiming I know these aren't ND NOS parts because they absolutely could be. But it looks weird. Anyone with unopened NOS ND bearing packs in their original ND packaging see them without the New Departures name stamps on top or not?!!
Like Rustjunkie and others have mentioned you can just push the old balls out of, and pop the new ones into, the old cages. So that's what I did. The balls were the same size old vs new.
Ball Swap:
You can see one of the original WL bearing cages from Gramp's bike doesn't have the New Departure stamp, but the holes are still clean and the top of that cage looks worn.
The new axle looks a little different in length than the original but it won't stick out of the hub too much further and everything can be properly adjusted still. The threads on the new axle are so much less munched up too. All the new cones and old nuts spin smoothly on the threads. So much better! The new axle has the cool circle ND logo in the center too. The cones look exactly the same with the ND WL stamps on top.