I have this set. The leading tab on the rear fender needs some attention and the trailing edge has some rattiness to it. The front is in ok shape with a little wear to the leading edge and a couple of dents. There's some crusty stuff on the underside that comes off with some effort. The fenders themselves are very solid and I think they'd clean up nice with an Oxalic Acid soak. Only asking $50 shipped. Let me know!